Published: · 3 min read · Written by the CalculatorGate team
Same shampoo, four stickers: "50% off", "buy one get one free", "buy 2 get 1 free" and "second one half price". They all sound generous, but the gap between them is bigger than it looks. It all comes down to one question: what does each bottle actually cost you?
Turn every deal into one number
The easiest way to compare is to work out the real discount per item. Say the shampoo normally costs $10:
- 50% off: one bottle for $5. That's a 50% discount.
- Buy one get one free: two bottles for $10, so $5 each. Also 50%, but you have to take two.
- Buy 2 get 1 free: three bottles for $20, so $6.67 each. Only 33% off.
- Second one half price: two bottles for $15, so $7.50 each. Just 25% off.
So the "half price" deal, the only one with the word "half" in it, is actually the weakest of the four.
The real question: how many do you need?
If you need one bottle, "buy one get one free" isn't a discount, it's an extra bottle. A second pack that sits in the cupboard until it expires wipes out the saving. Before you grab a multi-buy, ask yourself: will I really use all of this?
Multi-buys make sense for things that keep and that you use all the time: detergent, toilet paper, toothpaste. For fresh food, dairy or a product you're trying for the first time, a single-item discount is usually the smarter pick.
Watch the "was" price
A discount is only as honest as the price it starts from. If a store raises the price just before a sale and then takes 40% off, you may be paying the same as last month. Some places have rules about this: in the EU, the "was" price must be the lowest price of the previous 30 days. Still, the safest check is to track the price for a few weeks or compare it with another store.
Different sizes? Compare the unit price
Deals often mix pack sizes: 30% off a 16 oz bottle, full price on a 32 oz one. Compare the price per ounce, not the percentage. If the 16 oz bottle drops to $3.50, that's about 22 cents an ounce; if the 32 oz one costs $6, it's under 19 cents an ounce, and the full-price bottle wins.
A quick checklist
- Turn the deal into a price per item.
- Think about how many you'll actually use.
- Compare price per ounce or pound when sizes differ.
- Check whether the "was" price is real.
Hidden costs when you shop online
Online deals are a little trickier than in-store ones, because the price isn't the only thing on the bill:
- Shipping: 20% off a $30 item saves $6, and a $5.99 shipping fee takes almost all of it back.
- "Free shipping over $50": adding something you don't need to reach the limit often costs more than the shipping would have.
- Coupon codes: some apply to the sale price, others to the original price. Always check the final total at checkout.
- Buy now, pay later: splitting a payment is fine, but late fees can wipe out the discount.
Stacked discounts don't add up
If an item is 25% off and a coupon takes another 10% at checkout, the total discount is 32.5%, not 35%: $100 × 0.75 × 0.90 = $67.50. The second discount is applied to the already reduced price.
Doing this in your head at the checkout isn't easy. The discount calculator shows the sale price and your saving, and the unit price calculator tells you which pack size is cheapest in seconds.