calculatorgate.com
Home
/Up 10%, down 10%: why you don't end up where you started

Up 10%, down 10%: why you don't end up where you started

Raise a price by 10% and then cut it by 10%, and you won't get back to the original. Here's the simple math behind it, plus the difference between percent and percentage points.

Published: · 2 min read · Written by the CalculatorGate team

A store raises a price by 10%, then a week later runs a "10% off" sale. Is the price back where it was? Most people would say yes. The real answer is no: it ends up a little lower.

Let's look at the numbers

Say the item costs $100.

  • Up 10%: 100 × 1.10 = $110.
  • Then 10% off: 110 × 0.90 = $99.

You end at $99, not $100. The reason is simple: the second percentage is taken from the new number, not the original. The increase was 10% of $100, or $10. The discount is 10% of $110, or $11. One dollar disappears along the way.

Changing the order doesn't help: 10% off first ($90), then 10% up ($99). Still $99.

Bigger percentages, bigger gap

The effect grows with the size of the change. A 50% rise followed by a 50% fall turns $100 into $75. On the stock market, a share that drops 50% has to rise 100% just to get back to where it was. That's the math behind the old saying that losses are hard to make up.

Percent or percentage points?

The second common mix-up is between percent and percentage points. When a loan rate goes from 2% to 3%:

  • The rate rose by 1 percentage point (3 − 2 = 1).
  • But the rate rose by 50% (1 ÷ 2 × 100 = 50).

"Unemployment rose 2 points" and "unemployment rose 2%" are very different headlines. A 10% rate rising 2 points becomes 12%; rising 2% makes it only 10.2%.

Everyday examples

  • You got a 5% raise but prices rose 8% this year. Your buying power didn't go up 5%; it fell by about 2.8%: 1.05 ÷ 1.08 = 0.972.
  • An item is 20% off and there's an extra 10% at checkout. The total discount is 28%, not 30%: 0.80 × 0.90 = 0.72.
  • A company whose sales fell 50% last year and rose 50% this year is still 25% below where it was two years ago.

The one rule to remember

Don't add percentages that come one after another; multiply them. A 10% rise means multiplying by 1.10, a 10% fall by 0.90, and you multiply those together. The same rule works for raises, discounts, interest and inflation.

For a quick check, the percentage calculator shows how much a number went up or down in percent, and the inflation calculator shows what your pay is really worth after prices rise.